Recent Articles from Pat Murphy
Justices nix suit to lift Planned Parenthood Medicaid exclusion
A Medicaid beneficiary did not have an individual right to sue under §1983 to enjoin the state of South Carolina from terminating Planned Parenthood from its Medicaid program, a divided […]
SCOTUS limits ADA claims for disabled retirees
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that retirees not seeking work cannot sue under the ADA, rejecting a firefighter's disability discrimination claim.
Trial Court violates press’s right of access, suit says
Courthouse News sues Massachusetts Trial Court, alleging unconstitutional delays in press access to newly filed civil complaints.
Texas can’t go to court to block nuclear storage site, justices rule
The U.S. Supreme Court rules Texas can’t go to court to challenge a license issued by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to construct a facility in West Texas to store spent nuclear fuel.
SCOTUS sends refineries’ appeals of EPA actions to D.C. Circuit
SCOTUS rules EPA refinery waivers must be reviewed in the D.C. Circuit, not regional courts, pursuant to exception in the Clean Air Act’s venue provisions.
EPA’s denial of state plans subject to regional review, SCOTUS rules
SCOTUS rules that challenges to EPA state implementation plan denials in Oklahoma and Utah have venue within the regional circuit, not the D.C. Circuit, under the Clean Air Act.
Justices recognize limited jury trial right in prisoner cases
Supreme Court rules 5-4 that juries can decide if prisoners met PLRA exhaustion requirements when facts overlap with civil rights claims.
SCOTUS: Retailers can challenge FDA’s rejection of vaping products
The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 that vape retailers can challenge FDA denials of e-cigarette marketing applications under the Tobacco Control Act.
SCOTUS resuscitates challenge to Calif. emission rules
SCOTUS rules 7–2 that fuel producers have standing to challenge EPA approval of California’s electric vehicle and emissions regulations.
SCOTUS upholds Tenn. ban on transgender treatment for minors
The U.S. Supreme Court upheld Tennessee’s ban on transgender treatment for minors, ruling the law satisfies “rational basis” test under the Equal Protection Clause.
Judge: Musk shielded by arbitration clause in Tesla contracts
Elon Musk can compel arbitration in Tesla EV range lawsuit despite being sued personally, judge rules he qualifies as an affiliate and agent of Tesla.
Judge sounds alarm on RMV’s tardy license suspension hearings
A District Court judge rules RMV violated state law by delaying breath test license suspension hearings beyond the 15 days.


